Jamie Carlson is a business growth consultant and former corporate leader who spent her career in communications, brand, and strategic response roles at companies like Meta and PayPal. She’s the person executives turned to during their messiest transitions, the calm in the storm who could hold anything. While supporting these organizations through massive change and navigating motherhood at the same time, she experienced firsthand the personal cost that comes with that version of success. Today, Jamie runs Curical Consulting, where her work is grounded in a different definition of success, helping small business owners create growth that builds capacity instead of pressure. Her perspective is shaped not just by what she’s accomplished, but by what she’s had to unlearn along the way.
Jamie’s Story: When Safety Becomes the Cage
Jamie grew up in chaos. Military family, constant moves, raised by a young single mother who remarried multiple times. So she did what any smart, driven kid does: she decided her life would be different. She’d create the security, stability, and peace she never had growing up.
By her 20s, she was living the plan. Working multiple jobs, putting herself through Penn State after her entire family moved to Germany the week she started college, buying a condo she couldn’t afford because it was the only way she could figure out how to make school work. Every decision was about one thing: never being trapped, never being dependent, never experiencing the instability that defined her childhood.
Fast forward to her 30s. Jamie’s behind the scenes at Meta and PayPal during some of their most intense transitions, supporting C-suite executives through crises, holding everyone else’s chaos while appearing completely calm. On the outside, incredibly impressive. Great career, beautiful family, doing all the things.
But here’s what no one saw: Jamie was in chronic physical pain every single day for years. Nerve pain shooting through her neck and face, 24/7, that she just accepted as normal. She wore it like a badge of honor, actually, proof of how much she could handle. She was thriving in high-pressure environments because chaos was familiar. It’s what she grew up in. The crazier things got, the more valuable she became.
And she had no idea that the thing she’d spent her whole life running from was exactly what she kept choosing.
What we talk about in this episode:
- Why high achievers are addicted to chaos even while chasing peace. Jamie spent decades creating “safety” through achievement and control, only to realize she’d built a life that required constant crisis to feel normal. We unpack how the nervous system gets wired for chaos and why peace can feel more threatening than pressure when it’s all you’ve ever known.
- The physical cost of over-functioning that we ignore until our bodies force us to listen. For years, Jamie was in chronic nerve pain but saw it as proof of her strength and capacity. It wasn’t until pregnancy gave her body permission to relax that she realized she’d been living in a state of constant physical crisis, normalized and ignored because she was “good at handling it.”
- How motherhood became the breaking point that shifted everything. When Jamie held her first baby, she experienced something she’d been chasing her entire life: she wasn’t in pain. For the first time ever, her body relaxed. That moment cracked open the realization that the safety she’d been building through achievement had nothing to do with actually feeling safe.
- The trap of being “the calm one” everyone depends on. Jamie built her entire identity around being the person who could hold anything, the rock everyone turned to when things fell apart. We talk about how that role becomes a prison and what it costs when your worth is tied to your capacity to carry what no one else can.
- Why choosing to do nothing was scarier than any high-stakes corporate role. When Jamie got laid off from Meta, she had the financial security and support system she’d spent her life building. The scariest thing she could do wasn’t find another job. It was taking six months off. We explore why rest and presence feel more threatening than pressure for high achievers.
- What it actually means to stop proving and start being. Jamie’s entire life was driven by proving she could make it, handle it, create it on her own. She shares the ongoing work of shifting from “can I do this hard thing?” to “do I even want to?” and what becomes available when the goal isn’t the next achievement but actually feeling joy in the life you’ve already built.
- How to tell the difference between your intuition and your brain’s fear spirals. Jamie followed gut instincts that looked insane from the outside (buying a condo at 20 with no job, moving across the country to Austin after one weekend of virtual tours) but always worked out. We unpack how she’s learning to trust that knowing and think less.
- Why numbness is the real cost of success for high achievers. Jamie had everything she thought she wanted but couldn’t feel any of it. No joy, no sadness, just this flatline of “everything’s fine.” She shares what it’s taken to reconnect with feeling and why that’s been harder than any professional challenge she’s faced.
This episode is for you if you’ve ever:
- Spent your whole life creating safety but never actually felt safe
- Built something beautiful but can’t seem to feel it or enjoy it
- Been everyone’s rock while quietly crumbling inside
- Worn chronic pain or exhaustion like a badge of honor
- Thrived in chaos because calm feels unfamiliar and threatening
- Made every decision based on security but still feel trapped
- Been the person everyone turns to when things fall apart
- Wondered why you’re numb despite having everything you thought you wanted
- Known you should rest but literally don’t know how
- Achieved the external markers of success but feel nothing
How to Stop Choosing Chaos While Chasing Safety
Here’s what Jamie’s story reveals: the strategies that got you here, the over-functioning, the constant motion, the ability to handle anything, are the very things keeping you from what you actually want.
You spent your life becoming the strong one, the capable one, the person who doesn’t need help. And now that identity is a cage. You can’t stop moving because stillness feels like death. You can’t ask for help because being needed is how you know you matter. You can’t feel joy because your nervous system is still wired for the next crisis.
The cost isn’t just the chronic pain or the exhaustion or the numbness, though those are real. The cost is that you built the safe, stable, beautiful life you always wanted, and you can’t let yourself have it.
Get your free Bonus for this episode, The Safety Paradox Assessment, at lisacarpenter.ca/bonus
Ready to stop over-functioning and start actually feeling safe?
If Jamie’s story hit close to home, if you’re the person everyone leans on while you’re running on fumes, if you’ve achieved everything you thought would make you feel secure but you’re still waiting for the other shoe to drop, this is your pattern.
The Congruency Audit is where we look at the gap between the success you’ve built on the outside and what you’re actually feeling on the inside. We’ll identify the exact patterns keeping you stuck in over-functioning mode, the wounds driving your need to always be the strong one, and what it’s going to take for you to finally stop proving and start being present in the life you’ve already created.
Because you didn’t build all of this just to keep white-knuckling your way through it.
Book your free Congruency Audit: lisacarpenter.ca/audit
Connect with Jamie Carlson
LinkedIn: Jamie Carlson Company: Curical Consulting
It’s not either/or. It’s both/and. You can honor your drive and ambition AND stop choosing chaos. You can be the capable one AND let yourself be supported. You can create safety AND actually feel it.
This isn’t about optimizing the version of yourself you built to survive. It’s about creating congruence so the life you’ve built doesn’t just look good, it finally feels right.
